Carolyn Bryant Donham, the woman whose false accusation led to the brutal lynching of 14-year-old Emmett Till in Mississippi in 1955, has died in Louisiana. Despite the recent reexamination of her role in Till’s murder by a grand jury, Donham was never convicted for her part in the crime. The question remains: why was she never held accountable for the tragic death of an innocent Black teenager?

The story of Emmett Till’s murder is a heartbreaking chapter in American history. In August 1955, Till, a Black teenager from Chicago, was visiting relatives in Mississippi when he allegedly whistled at Carolyn Bryant Donham, a white woman who worked at a local grocery store. Donham’s husband, Roy Bryant, and his half-brother, J.W. Milam, brutally beat Till, shot him, and then tied a 70-pound fan to his body and threw him in the Tallahatchie River.

Also read | Who was Carolyn Bryant Donham? Woman accused of Emmett Till’s lynching death dies at 88

Despite overwhelming evidence of their guilt, an all-white jury acquitted Bryant and Milam of Till’s murder. Donham’s testimony was instrumental in securing their acquittal, as she claimed that Till had grabbed her and made lewd comments to her in the store. It was later revealed that her testimony was a lie, and that Till had never touched her.

In 2007, Donham broke her silence about the case in an interview with author Timothy Tyson. She admitted that she had lied about Till’s behavior in the store, and that he had never touched her. Donham also revealed that Bryant and Milam had not only confessed to Till’s murder, but had also forced her to participate in their cover-up.

In 2017, the United States Department of Justice reopened its investigation into Till’s murder, and a grand jury in Mississippi considered charging Donham with perjury. However, the grand jury ultimately decided not to indict her, citing the statute of limitations on perjury.

So why was Carolyn Bryant Donham never held accountable for her role in Emmett Till’s murder? The answer lies in the systemic racism and prejudice that was pervasive in the American South at the time. The all-white jury that acquitted Bryant and Milam was not willing to convict two white men of killing a Black teenager, and Donham’s false testimony played a critical role in their acquittal. Even after Donham admitted to lying about Till’s behavior, there was no guarantee that she would face justice. The statute of limitations on perjury had long since expired, and there was little appetite among prosecutors for pursuing charges against an elderly white woman.

Also read | Who was Roy Bryant, Carolyn Bryant Donham’s husband?

In death, Carolyn Bryant Donham leaves behind a legacy of racial violence and injustice. While she may have never been held accountable for her role in Emmett Till’s murder, her name will forever be associated with one of the most shameful episodes in American history.